An international team investigating this concept has just published its findings in Nature Communications. Working in the mountainous regions of Ecuador, the researchers tested five different scenarios and found afforestation and intense pasturing to be particularly effective, clearly increasing the environmental and economic value of abandoned farmlands. The scientists were drawn from universities and institutes in Germany, Ecuador and Costa Rica.
Every year, 130,000 square kilometres of rainforest disappear from the face of the earth – an area equivalent to the size of Greece. The majority of this land is cleared for agricultural development – even in tropical mountain areas. But these fields are quickly overgrown with weeds, with Bracken being particularly tenacious. It cannot be permanently eliminated using herbicides or by burning the land. As a result, farmers often abandon the land after a few short years and start clearing new areas of forest.
"This cycle has to be broken," explains Professor Thomas Knoke from the Institute of Forest Management at Technische Universität München (TUM), the lead author of the study. "We've been investigating whether this abandoned pasture land can be recultivated, and if so, how."
The team did not just look at the economic benefit when evaluating the different concepts, but also took environmental and socio-cultural criteria into consideration. They also factored in issues such as the amount of carbon dioxide and nitrogen assimilated by plants and soil, biomass production, soil quality, impact on climate, water management and acceptance among farmers.
The area under investigation of approximately 150 hectares is located in the Ecuadorian Andes at an altitude of between 1,800 and 2,100 metres. The researchers looked at five different concepts:
No land use – abandoned land is left to nature
Afforestation 1 – planting a native species of alder
Afforestation 2 – introduction of a non-native pine species
Extensive pasturing – mechanical weed control followed by initial fertilisation and land use
Intense pasturing – chemical weed control and land use with regular fertilisation
Afforestation with alder and pine species proved particularly sustainable. In addition, forested regions offer the best protection against erosion in the long term. "Our study also showed that afforestation with the native Andean alder had a much more positive impact on the climate and water balance than the other land use options," adds Professor Jörg Bendix from Phillips-Universität Marburg.
Engaging the farmers – a key factor
Typical rainforest flora and fauna are also able to gradually recolonise afforested regions. Intense pasturing scored much higher on the ecological scale than extensive pasturing. The team confirmed economic benefits stemmed from the sale of wood (afforestation) or the sale of meat and milk (pasturing). Alder plantations achieved the greatest financial returns.
A survey conducted among land users showed that the majority of livestock farmers also viewed afforestation as the best land use option due to the positive ecological balance and greater long-term earnings potential. "If we want recultivation concepts to be a success, the people using the land have to be engaged," elaborates Bendix.
The sustainable land use concepts all come at a cost, however. Over a period of twenty years, farmers who do not use slash-and-burn techniques are exposed to an annual loss of earnings. This amounts to 87 dollars per hectare for afforestation and 100 dollars per hectare for intense pasturing. The researchers regard compensation for recultivation as an important incentive for encouraging famers to replant abandoned grazing land. In the long term, trade with CO2 certificates could also provide an additional source of income.
The researchers also believe that their study could be used as a reference for evaluating recultivation concepts in other tropical mountain forests, for example in Brazil or Africa. "Abandoned agricultural land is a huge resource that is not being harnessed," summarises Thomas Knoke. "The German Research Foundation is currently funding a number of projects that are working with farmers in Ecuador to implement the findings of the study," concludes Erwin Beck, professor at the University of Bayreuth and the man who started the project in Ecuador 17 years ago.
Platform for biodiversity, ecosystem monitoring and research in South Ecuador
Agriculture and rainforest protection - a contradiction?
Nature Communications submitted paper/article